Spirit Island: Nature Incarnate Game Crate Expansion

I wish I'd read some of the other reviews here before purchasing. This expansion provides no additional storage space for spirit boards, which is my main issue with the base crate - not all spirit boards from all of the game expansions fit in the crate, so a few have to be kept separate. This expansion does nothing to solve that issue. Furthermore, the new components have no anchor points (raised curves) to help them fit in with the other components, so the pieces are left floating around in the crate, making it more difficult to re-assemble. The dedicated storage containers for deeps/vitality/quake tokens is nice, but they fit fine in a baggie in the base crate, so they aren't providing much value. Lastly, the quality on the components seems like a drop from the original (some measurements are a bit off, and the symbol and text imprints are much fuzzier).

Having built all of the components, I've decided against using this expansion altogether; it doesn't solve the spirit board storage problem, and increases the crate volume while making the component fit sloppier. I would not recommend this to other potential purchasers, and would suggest a re-design to address some of the described issues. I've been happy with other Broken Token products, but this one is a miss. I'll be using foil spirit panels instead of the cardboard version to solve the spirit board storage issue.

Where is the Broken Token quality ?
This item doesn't have the same size of the box and even with glue nothing stay together.
Finaly I can store all the stuff in the big box and it fit perfectly I clearly regret my purchase

The middle portion that extends the box height had a different measurement as the crate (3-4 mm off). As such it doesn’t sit perfectly in the middle and keeps wobbling. Woodworking is all about precision, and for the price paid I expected a little more rigor in the measurements. Otherwise, it nicely fits everything it says it fits.

Title above mentions it. I saw another review here that was also disappointed to find that the storage container addition does not provide a solution to add in these boards. It is a stand-alone version of the game, but it is made backwards compatible so that those boards/cards can be played with the full Spirit Island game. Unfortunate find after building it, but maybe one day we'll get something extra to help solve this issue.

This is exactly as advertised. The crate expansion and replacement trays work great for the base game and all expansions. Maybe I just pack mine differently from everyone else, but I had no trouble fitting every component and Spirit card from every expansion (including Horizons) in the crate with this expansion.

The only complaint I might have is the price, but I'm happy with what I got.

Special note should be given to customer service on this one. The original crate extension I received was slightly too large (about 1/8 inch too wide and deep). While it was able to support the crate just fine, it looked weird with it not being flush with the sides of the crate, sticking out too much. I reached out to Broken Token about this with some photos, and they immediately send me a replacement which is exactly the correct size. Great job, guys!

Order arrived at expected time, but was missing a part Central to assembly, now to wait another month before I can complete it

It fits all my expansions very well. The only change I would add is a note that some of the new pieces actually replace old pieces rather than the addition being entirely supplemental.

Great expansion… if you do not have all previous expansions. There is no extra room for the 8 New spirits. Very, very disappointing for such a expensive addon.

We have all of the expansions for Spirit island. This storage solution works great. Everything fits tightly and it was easy to assemble. Really love the look of the top box cover too!

As this claims to be a crate expansion for the Nature Incarnate expansion I assumed that this would fit all prior expansions as well. Unfortunately it does not. Almost everything fits fine... except for the spirit panels. All my spirit panels from previous game material fill the "panel tray" (from the base spirit island organizer) flush to the top. This "Nature Incarnate Game Crate Expansion" however does not include additional space for Spirit panels and I don't even have "Horizons of Spirit Island".
Everything else fits nicely although there are a few token trays that don't seem to have a purpose.
If it wasn't for the Spirit Panels I would have given this 4 or 5 Stars