A bunch of these coins came with a buff job far inferior to that pictured on the website. This results in less of the artificial patina being removed, making the coins look more bronze than gold or even copper. I will have to try using a wire brush to complete the factory-incomplete buff job. Three stars. On top of that they sent me an incorrect coin from the magic gold set, so I knocked off an additional star. I also knocked off an additional star because I opted out of email updates but they still hounded me via email for this review, very disrespectful. For the price I paid, it was a pretty disappointing experience compared to just purchasing the cheapo chineseium coins from Amazon. I recommend the 35 mm jumbo gold coins if you absolutely must buy from this company. At least they actually look gold in appearance, although they are not stackable and I don't know how long the finish will last. Oh and I almost forgot to mention that their Etsy shop automatically applies a discount that their online store doesn't, which feels scum-baggish to me as a customer who simply wants the best deal without wasting a bunch of my time and effort scouring Google for coupon codes like it's 2014.